YA literature has been part of teens over the course of 40 years, but nowadays, these books have been receiving an outstanding amount of hate and disgust. People, mainly parents, and authors have been debating on limiting access to these books because these books have been traumatizing and nauseating. However, YA fiction has been adored and been with adolescents for so long that limiting access to these books would be imprudent decision and will most likely cause more anarchy within teenagers, considering how chaotic the situation has already become.
One of the reasons why access to YA books should not be limited is because adolescents are always connecting to characters within these books and are encouraged by them. For instance, in Sherman Alexie (author of award winning teen novel, The Absolute True Diary of A Part Time Indian) wrote an article, Why the Best Kids Books are Written in Blood, where steps in and explains why YA books have been written with some disturbing content. He mentions a troubling boy whose father is forcing him into being in the military. The young boy doesn't want to and would dedicate his life into writing books. The boy even says, “I want to be myself. Just like in your book.” He refers to Sherman Alexie’s book, The Absolute True Diary of A Part Time Indian, and mentions how he wants to be like the character in this book. We've learned to use the text to self strategy when making reading responses, so banning books would make this strategy useless. Also, in this article, Sherman Alexie mentions the fact that YA books have gruesome content because teens have been through these harsh and dark themes of these books. He states that he gets a lot of mail everyday from teenagers who love his book. A lot of them have even been through" rape, family lost, depression, gang warfare" and a lot more. These teens have specified how much Sherman Alexie’s book meant to them. This sums up the fact that YA books are meaningful to adolescents and should not be banned in any way, or anywhere.
Another reason why access to YA books should not be limited is because these books also been around for educational and entertainment purposes and there is no law that prevents readers from reading these kind of books and writers for writing in a dark way. For instance, in the article, Teen Fiction Plots are Darker and Starker, by William Porter, he mentions a quote from famous author, David Levithan, saying, "Writers today feel this freedom to write what they want, light or dark...When you feel the world is broken, as an author you create an alternative world to try and fix it." What he is trying to say is that authors write for a purpose, to express their feelings and show teenagers that there are people who go through a time, but just show it in a fictional way. In addition, we've learned to use the text to self strategy when making reading responses, so banning books would make this strategy useless. Thus, limiting access to these books is a dreadful decision.
In contrast, parents urge readers to stop reading YA literature because many of the stories contain sinister content that can fright teens. They claim that YA literature can give teens a bad view of Earth and give them ideas of being in a gang or do anything immoral. For instance, in Meghan Cox Gurdon’s article, “Darkness too Visible,” Ms. Gurdon claims that YA fiction contains too much dark content that include, rape, drug addiction, suicide, and more. Although this is true, it is not for the wrong, it is for entertaining, and education. Ms.Gurdon keeps generalizing the issue as if she doesn't know much about it. YA literature is still has its benefits. In addition, YA books cannot be traumatizing when adolescents are already going through the horrors that are within these books.
All in all, the situation on YA books is dim-witted. There isn't a point in banning YA books when they have been a great success for the past years and have help change the lives of teens. Although there are books with gruesome content, banning these books won’t make the situation better. Do people honestly think that books will be banned for no one to read?